How to Choose a Plastic Surgeon: 10 Essential Tips for Safe Results

Choosing the right plastic surgeon is the single most important decision you will make in your cosmetic surgery journey. The surgeon you select directly determines your safety, your results, and your overall experience. Yet with thousands of practitioners advertising cosmetic procedures, it can be overwhelming to separate truly qualified experts from the rest.

This guide walks you through 10 essential tips that will help you identify a skilled, trustworthy plastic surgeon and avoid costly or dangerous mistakes. Whether you are considering rhinoplasty, a facelift, or Botox injections, these principles apply universally.

1. Verify Board Certification

Board certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (ABPS) is the gold standard credential. This certification requires completion of an accredited plastic surgery residency, passing rigorous written and oral examinations, and maintaining ongoing education. Do not confuse this with certifications from other boards that sound similar but have far less stringent requirements.

You can verify any surgeon's certification at the ABPS website or through the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) directory. A board-certified plastic surgeon has completed at least six years of surgical training, including a minimum of three years specifically in plastic surgery.

2. Evaluate Their Specialization and Experience

• Procedure Volume Matters: Surgeons who perform a high volume of a specific procedure develop refined techniques and better handle complications. Ask for their annual case numbers.
• Subspecialty Focus: Some surgeons focus on facial procedures, others on body contouring or breast surgery. Seek a surgeon whose primary focus aligns with your goals.
• Fellowship Training: Additional fellowship training in aesthetic surgery, craniofacial surgery, or microsurgery signals advanced expertise beyond standard residency.
• Years in Practice: While newer surgeons can be excellent, a track record spanning multiple years provides more data on long-term outcomes and patient satisfaction.

3. Review Before-and-After Photos Carefully

A surgeon's before-and-after gallery is one of the most powerful tools for evaluating their aesthetic sensibility and technical skill. Look for patients with similar anatomy to yours and assess whether the results appear natural, balanced, and consistent across multiple cases.

Be wary of galleries that only show dramatic transformations, use inconsistent lighting or angles between before and after shots, or feature very few examples. A reputable surgeon will have an extensive gallery with standardized medical photography.

4. Schedule Multiple Consultations

Never commit to the first surgeon you meet. Scheduling consultations with at least two to three board-certified plastic surgeons gives you a basis for comparison. Pay attention to how each surgeon listens to your goals, explains the procedure, discusses risks, and manages your expectations.

During your consultation, a quality surgeon will perform a thorough examination, explain multiple approaches, be honest about what is achievable, and give you a detailed breakdown of costs. If a surgeon promises perfect results or dismisses your concerns, that is a red flag.

5. Ask the Right Questions

1. Are you board-certified by the ABPS? This should be a straightforward yes. Any hesitation or redirection is a concern.
2. How many times have you performed this specific procedure? Look for experienced practitioners with high case volumes in your desired procedure.
3. What is your complication rate? Every surgeon has complications. An honest surgeon will share their rate and explain how they handle them.
4. Where will the surgery be performed? The facility should be accredited by AAAASF, JCAHO, or be a licensed hospital.
5. Who administers anesthesia? A board-certified anesthesiologist or certified registered nurse anesthetist (CRNA) should manage your anesthesia.
6. What does the total cost include? Get an itemized quote covering surgeon fees, anesthesia, facility, garments, and follow-up visits.
7. What is the revision policy? Understand what happens if you need a touch-up or correction.
8. Can I speak with previous patients? Patient references provide honest insight into the full experience.

6. Investigate the Surgical Facility

Where your surgery takes place matters as much as who performs it. Ensure the operating facility is accredited and equipped with emergency protocols. Accredited facilities undergo regular inspections and must meet rigorous safety standards for equipment, staffing, and emergency preparedness.

If surgery is performed in the surgeon's office-based operating room, confirm it holds accreditation from the American Association for Accreditation of Ambulatory Surgery Facilities (AAAASF) or an equivalent body. Hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers are typically accredited by default.

7. Spot the Red Flags

• Bargain Pricing: Prices significantly below market average often indicate cut corners on safety, facility quality, or surgeon qualifications.
• High-Pressure Sales Tactics: A reputable surgeon never pressures you to book immediately, offers "limited-time" discounts, or makes you feel rushed.
• Lack of Transparency: If a surgeon avoids answering questions about credentials, complication rates, or costs, this is a serious concern.
• No Board Certification: Any doctor with a medical license can legally perform cosmetic procedures, regardless of training. Without ABPS certification, you have no assurance of specialized training.
• Operating in Non-Accredited Facilities: Surgery in a non-accredited facility puts you at higher risk.

8. Read Reviews but Read Them Wisely

Online reviews provide useful data but require critical interpretation. Look for patterns across many reviews rather than fixating on individual testimonials. Consistently positive feedback about communication, results, and follow-up care is a strong indicator. Consistently negative feedback about the same issues is a clear warning.

Check multiple platforms including RealSelf, Google Reviews, Healthgrades, and Yelp. Be skeptical of profiles with only five-star reviews and no detailed commentary, as these may be curated or fabricated.

9. Assess the Consultation Experience

10. Trust Your Instincts

After completing your research, verifying credentials, reviewing galleries, and attending consultations, trust your gut feeling. You should feel confident, comfortable, and cared for by your chosen surgeon. If something feels off, even if you cannot articulate exactly what, continue your search. Your body and your safety deserve a surgeon you trust completely.

The relationship between patient and plastic surgeon is a deeply personal one. You are entrusting someone with your appearance and your health. That trust must be earned through demonstrated competence, transparent communication, and genuine care for your wellbeing.

How Our App Helps You Prepare

One of the most valuable things you can bring to a plastic surgery consultation is a clear visual of your desired outcome. Our AI-powered plastic surgery simulator lets you upload your photo and preview realistic results for rhinoplasty, Botox, lip fillers, breast augmentation, and more. Walking into a consultation with a simulated preview gives you and your surgeon a shared starting point, making the conversation more productive and your expectations more aligned.

Preview Your Results Today

Use our AI-powered plastic surgery simulator to visualize how different procedures will look on you before making any decisions.